In a homage to Heart Break Kids "Best Games" post, which do you think are the most over-rated games? Not the worst games as such, but the ones which grabbed high scores and you felt that they weren't deserved. Vote for ONE klik game and ONE commercial game. And try not to turn this thread into any personal attacks.
I like Carmageddon, it's not exactly sophisticated entertainment but it's a bit of a laugh.
I think Halo's vastly overrated. That is, I'm intrigued by the plot and can see why people like it, but it just seems slow and awkward compared to many other FPSsesses.
I hate SatanSam for one reason and one reason alone; instead of giving me more control over my character, it took it away. That jump shot is a perfect example.
Eternal Daughter is an absolutely beatiful game, but I just never found it that fun. It's impressive, but certainly isn't the end-all Klik game that everyone treats it as.
Oblivion is just Morrowind with a new coat of pain, with all the same problems of it's predecessor. There is no style to the art direction at all, and the graphics aren't even that great from a purely technical perspective. The combat is boring, the storyline is cliche, and the load times are ridiculous.